This post is the second in a series exploring the Nine Hallmarks of Great Pedagogy through the lens of Imaginative Inquiry and Mantle of the Expert (MoE). In this post, we focus on Hallmark 2: the interplay of teacher knowledge, behaviour, and beliefs.
In recent years the primacy of domain knowledge has become a defining narrative in English education. Everywhere you look there are links on school websites to their ‘knowledge-rich curriculum’ and their ‘deep learning in subject disciplines’. This reassertion of knowledge came about as a backlash against the last Labour government’s curriculum review led by Sir Jim Rose, which foregrounded skills, creativity, and cross-curricular learning, particularly in the primary phase. The Rose review challenged the compartmentalisation of knowledge and suggested that relevance and application should take precedence. Critics argued this approach diluted disciplinary rigor, especially in secondary education, prompting a return to a more traditional focus on subject-based instruction often drawing on the work of E.D. Hirsch and cognitive science.
As a result, rather than secondary education becoming more like primary, primary education became more like secondary. The ‘Gove’ National Curriculum, published in 2014, reinforced the organisation of learning into subject silos and reinstated a focus on core knowledge across disciplines. This was further amplified by Ofsted’s implementation of subject-specific ‘deep dives’ – a form of inspection that required detailed tracking of curriculum implementation in individual subjects. While intended to raise standards, these deep dives placed immense pressure on subject leads, particularly in small primary schools where one teacher often wears multiple hats. The result has been a narrowing of the curriculum in many settings, with less time for integrated, imaginative learning, and a growing sense that expertise is about compliance rather than curiosity.
If you are reading this from another part of the world, consider it a salient lesson. What may begin as a well-meaning effort to sharpen focus on disciplinary knowledge can, over time, tip into rigid accountability structures that constrain professional judgment and creativity. The English example shows how the pendulum swing toward knowledge, when accompanied by high-stakes inspection regimes, can lead to unintended consequences: a loss of curricular breadth and an experience for children that feels like they are being ‘delivered’ the curriculum rather than engaging with it. It’s a reminder that how we frame and assess knowledge matters as much as the knowledge itself.
I’m not knocking the importance of knowledge; it is the fundamental building block of all learning. One of the most effective ways for any teacher to improve their practice is to deepen their subject knowledge. And if you’re a primary teacher, that means knowing as much as you can about what your students are learning across the curriculum.
For instance, if you’re planning next term’s work and have been asked to teach the Stone Age, your first step should be to learn as much as possible about that period. When I began teaching, that meant a trip to the local library, poring over books – often written for an academic audience – and trying to work out what was relevant for my class. Thankfully, we now have the internet and, more recently, AI, which can be an incredible time-saver. You can simply ask: “Tell me what I need to know about the Stone Age to teach my Year 3 class” and get a list that would have taken hours, if not days, to compile in the past.
The problem with the knowledge rich agenda is not curriculum, its pedagogy. As human beings we are really bad at learning things when we’re bored. Think about your own time in school, can you remember anything from the lessons when you were bored, except being bored? I can remember one maths lesson where we were learning logarithms. I couldn’t work it out and didn’t feel motivated to put in the effort. Being a cheeky bugger, I asked the teacher, “Why are we learning this?” The teacher replied, “It’ll be in the exam.” Fair enough, but it didn’t make me less bored and although I can remember the lesson and how I felt, I can’t remember the content.
We can overcome this learning problem by repetition and tests. This is how I learnt logarithms, I was motivated to pass the exam so I kept working at it, doing the exercises and the tests until it stuck in my long-term memory, just long enough for me to get through maths paper. After that, I forgot about it and never used them again. I suspect this is the truth for many students, I know it was for my own children, all of whom have gone on to have successful experiences at university.
How much better, and how much more effective, it would be if the students understood what they were doing and why it was worth learning? This is where fictional contexts can help and why education should spend more time researching and developing these methods.
Imagine, for example, if my maths teacher had spent a bit of time at the beginning of the term developing with us a fictional context called, ‘Uncovering the Code: Logarithms and the Secrets of the Forgotten Archive’? with the following narrative:
Deep beneath the city lies a long-forgotten archive – sealed for centuries, rumoured to contain the knowledge of an advanced civilisation. A tremor disturbs the foundations, revealing a hidden door etched with strange symbols and sequences. The Agency for Mathematical Decipherment recruits a team of cryptologists, mathematicians, and analysts. Their mission: to decode the archive’s logarithmic language, interpret its secrets, and protect the data before it falls into the wrong hands. But as they dig deeper, they realise they’re not the only ones searching…
I’d have been all over that. There would have been no question about why we were learning logarithms. Of course, this way of teaching isn’t without its complications. It takes time to plan – although even that has become much easier with the support of AI. The fictional context I just described took seconds to generate using the ChatGPT app, Mantle Planner, with the prompt: “Create a fictional context for 13-year-olds learning about logarithms and other relevant maths knowledge.”
Yes, some time will be needed, especially at the beginning, to establish the context and build the Team. But the payoff is enormous. And more than worth the effort.
In this kind of approach, knowledge becomes embedded in the process of investigation and meaning making. If students are intrigued by the story – if it holds enough mystery, tension, and consequence – then the purpose of learning, and the motivation to remember, becomes intrinsic.
This isn’t about having ‘fun’ (another common criticism of this approaches), although students are likely to enjoy themselves. It’s about contextualising their learning and giving it meaning and purpose. It doesn’t matter that the story isn’t real. That’s not how stories work. Stories create immersion and empathy. They help us see ourselves (or possible versions of ourselves) and others, inside a fiction that feels urgent and important. This is what drives the narrative and makes the learning exciting.
Imagine, being excited about logarithms!
Creating stories for learning, where students are cast as people with power and responsibility within the fiction, isn’t a superfluous add-on to make the lesson fun – it’s a pedagogical choice rooted in purpose and effectiveness. It’s a way of structuring learning so that knowledge is not just received but used, applied, and made meaningful in action. Within the fiction, what students do matters. They are not just learning content – they are using that content in ways that feel consequential.
The implications for teaching are significant. I started this paper talking about how the emphasis on knowledge has, in many cases, narrowed the curriculum, squeezed out creativity, and made learning something that happens to children, rather than something they are engaged in. The consequences have largely been unintended. Most advocates of the knowledge-rich curriculum didn’t set out to make school boring – but that, by and large is where we are at.
Yet it doesn’t have to be this way. There are methods – some developed and refined over decades – that offer a different path. Approaches like Mantle of the Expert and Imaginative Inquiry show how knowledge can be taught with rigour and depth, while still fostering students’ curiosity and making learning feel both relevant and important. Knowledge is the foundational building block of any curriculum, but it is not the be all and end all.
Memorising dates and data until they stick long enough to get through an exam might be enough for those students (like my 13-year-old self) who are motivated by such things. But they are not everything. And it’s not enough. There is a better way, one that all teachers can learn to use, if we make space for it in training and support.
Discover more from Try this book
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.