This is the third in a series of reflections exploring the nine hallmarks of great pedagogy through the lens of Imaginative Inquiry and Mantle of the Expert.
Curiosity and young minds
Every teacher should spend some time working in a nursery classroom. They are places of excitement, non-stop activity, and unexpected events. I’m not talking at the end of the year, when the children have learnt the rules and conventions of being in school, but at the start, the very first few days when the whole experience is totally new.
My first time in a nursery was an eye opener. I was an infant teacher, used to working in years one and two, where the children would come into class, sit on the carpet, and, by and large, listen to what I had to say. During my first two minutes in a nursery, I realised I had to find a whole new array of skills and ways of getting attention. Nothing I had learned in the past was of much good, the rules and conventions I had taken for granted were no use with these children, they didn’t know what they were.
The next time I went in I took a large sheet of paper and started to draw. The children gathered round, bumping into each other, some complaining they couldn’t see. One of them said, “what are you drawing?”
I stopped and said, “I’ll tell you, but first can everybody move back so that everyone can see.”
This took a little while, but with the help of the adults, all the children were eventually sat in a bit of circle. I went back to my drawing.
“It’s a flowerpot!” one of them said.
“Yes,” I confirmed, and I started to draw a flower and some leaves. “The problem is, whenever I grow my flowers, this happens.” I started drawing holes in the leaves.
“What’s that?” one of them asked.
“It’s a hole.” I replied, “I don’t know what’s making them, but something is coming into my garden and eating my flowers!”
“Oh!” said several of the children.
“What do you think it is?” I asked, knowing they had been reading the Hungry Caterpillar recently.
“A bee!” one of them shouted.
“Do bees eat leaves?” I asked.
“No,” they tended to agree.
“A caterpillar!” one of them suddenly called out, making the connection.
“Oh,” I said, “do you think so? That’s a real problem. I don’t know how to catch caterpillars. Do you?”
“Oh, yes,” they said, “We know.”
“Excellent,” I said, “will you help me?”
“Yes, of course,” they said.
“That’s wonderful. I’ve got some paper here, could you draw how you are going to catch the caterpillars, so they stop eating my flowers.”
The children set to work.
Starting from Uncertainty
I’m telling you this story because, as teachers, we take so much for granted – how classrooms are organised, how children are expected to behave, and how the curriculum is taught. But in a nursery, especially in those early days, none of this can be relied on. The usual routines and expectations are not yet in place. You have to find other ways to gain the children’s attention, to hold it, and to offer them genuine reasons to engage.
There are important lessons here for all teachers. Critical among them is the need to weave children’s interests and curiosity into the curriculum, rather than treating the curriculum as something fixed and distant, handed down to be delivered. Instead, it needs to be made alive, something the children can make sense of, connect with, and want to explore. That’s not always easy; most curriculum documents are not written with this in mind. But shaping them into something meaningful – that’s our job. And not just in nursery.
In What Makes Great Pedagogy?, one of the nine claims from research urges educators to think clearly about long-term learning goals. Not just the immediate outcomes of a lesson, but the kinds of understanding, capability, and purpose we hope will endure.
The Seeds of Long-Term Learning
Let’s look back at this brief lesson and see how it holds up.
On the surface, it might seem like a simple drawing activity, a way to settle restless children. But beneath it lies a more ambitious intent: to orient the children into a world of shared purpose, to offer them a role (problem solvers) and to begin to form a narrative frame within which learning can take place. This wasn’t about ticking off early learning goals or rehearsing isolated skills; it was about establishing a meaningful context for learning, one that could stretch and develop over time.
This is where long-term learning goals start to come into focus – not as targets on a planning sheet, but as threads running through the weeks and months of classroom life. The goal wasn’t simply to teach children about caterpillars or the letter C. It was to invite them into a mode of being in the classroom: curious, collaborative, and responsible. In Mantle of the Expert terms, we might say we are inducting them into a fiction where they have expertise to offer and ideas on how to solve problems.
When we plan with the long view in mind, we begin to see how today’s small moments – drawing, sharing ideas, helping someone out – might contribute to something more enduring. We start to ask different questions of our planning: What kind of learners are we hoping these children will become? What dispositions do we want to nurture? How can the work we do together lay foundations for that future?
This doesn’t mean abandoning curriculum goals. Rather, it means holding them in creative tension with the story worlds we construct with and for our students. It means resisting the temptation to fragment learning into disconnected parts and instead seeking coherence over time. In Mantle of the Expert, this coherence comes through the imagined context – a company protecting endangered species, a team rebuilding a lost city, a group of archivists uncovering stories from the past. Within such contexts, curriculum content is not simply ‘covered’, but explored, questioned, and made meaningful.
Of course, this kind of work takes time. It asks us to trust the process, to look beyond the outcomes of a single lesson and attend to the deeper patterns that unfold in learning. And it asks us to think of ourselves not as deliverers of knowledge but as mediators – crafting the conditions in which students can see themselves as capable, connected, and successful.
A common strategy in this kind of work is called ‘person with a problem,’ where an adult, often the teacher, plays the role of someone in need of help. The children are brought into the fiction as people with the expertise and skills to help them out. This doesn’t turn the children into real -world experts; they are still children with limited knowledge and experience. But it does temporarily position them as people with agency, power, and responsibility, qualities they enjoy but rarely experience in everyday life.
Discover more from Try this book
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.